The Great T Debate – one or two pieces for your slate hearth?
Looking for a slate hearth? Over the years here at Manthorpe Slate, we have made 10,000s of slate hearths with great success Our trade customers, in the majority, purchase two pieces hearths – one for the fireplace recess and one part to sit in the room, whilst single piece hearths are in the minority.
Why is this when they are potentially more aesthetically pleasing with no joint line between the front and back? Some might say easier it is because they are easier to fit as there is no struggling to align the two pieces. One answer might be cost -T-shapes are a bit more expensive to reflect the extra waste and time to manufacture . However the cost between a two piece slate hearth and a single piece is not significantly different. The main reason is compatibility. Slate is an incredible material – able to withstand great stresses in both tensile and compression, however even slate has its limits. A hot stove placed upon a T- shaped hearth can cause a complex series of compression and tensile stresses in the material. The slate hearth will want to expand where it is hottest, and where the slate is still cool in the room, it will cause compressive stresses. If the heat is significantly high, the slate will eventually stress relieve itself in the form of a crack. To prevent this from happening, slate hearths are often supplied in two pieces to reduce the thermal gradient over the piece the stove sits upon in the recess, as this can now expand unhindered . It will only push as its expands on the front piece, causing a slight compression stress and can’t create a tensile stress in the front piece.
Its not always necessary to have your slate hearth in two pieces however. For instance, if the stove runs a cool hearth temperature for example, it has a log store underneath, there will be very little thermal stress into the hearth. The only consideration then would be if you could lift the often heavy hearth and bed it correctly in a T-shape configuration. We do have a few hints and tips on this in our information leaflet that we give to customers upon purchase of a slate hearth to help overcome this issue .

So to recap – two pieces are best if you don’t know how hot your stove will heat the hearth or you want to save a few pennies. One piece is great if the stove runs a cool hearth temperature and you fancy a bit of a work out!
Please take some time to visit the bespoke hearth page on our website and as always, please do contact us at Manthorpe Slate if you would like any further help or to order your slate hearth!
