Which hearth slate?

Choosing the Right Hearth Slate: An Unbiased Guide

When selecting a hearth slate, one of the first considerations is appearance and durability. A honed slate offers a smooth, sophisticated finish that looks sleek and refined, whereas a riven slate provides a more natural, textured appearance that is softer and more forgiving of scratches.

Understanding Slate Finishes

There are two primary types of finishes for hearth slates:

  • Honed Slate: This slate is machined to a silky-smooth finish, making it visually appealing and easy to clean. However, it can show scratches more prominently, much like a glass table with a clear surface.
  • Riven Slate: Created by splitting the slate along its natural layers using chisels, this finish is by far the most durable. Its textured surface helps to conceal scratches, much like frosted glass masks imperfections better than clear glass.

A Review of Slate Types

At Manthorpe Slate, with over 25 years of experience supplying hearth slates, we have worked with various types of slate and analyzed their strengths and weaknesses. Below is an unbiased assessment of the most popular slate options:

Brazilian Slate (Dark Grey)

Brazilian slate emerged in the market relatively recently and was initially valued for its consistent color. However, it has several drawbacks:

  • It is not a true metamorphic rock but rather classified as shale, making it prone to delamination in thicker formats (20mm-30mm), especially in outdoor conditions.
  • Over time, inconsistent quality has become an issue, with swirling cracks (often referred to as vents) appearing.
  • Scratches on Brazilian riven slate are difficult to blend in because the material is not uniform in color throughout. Deep scratches can expose a lighter underlayer that cannot be darkened back.
  • Chips are also more noticeable if the underside is a different color than the top surface.

Welsh Slate

About a decade ago, Welsh slate—particularly from the Cwt-y-Bugail quarry—was widely available and highly regarded.

  • It is considered the “king of slates,” being exceptionally durable and aesthetically pleasing.
  • However, riven Welsh slate in large formats has become increasingly difficult to source, as the quarry mainly focuses on roof tiles.
  • Honed Welsh slate remains more accessible but is typically more expensive.

Cumbrian Slate

  • Availability of riven Cumbrian slate is very limited.
  • Honed Cumbrian slate carries a high price tag and is restricted in plan size, making it less suitable for larger hearths.

Italian Slate (The Preferred Choice at Manthorpe Slate)

Manthorpe Slate primarily focuses on high-quality Italian riven slate for several reasons:

  • It maintains the classic slate appearance with a beautifully textured surface that is not overly uneven, ensuring stability for stoves.
  • It is consistent in color, so chips or scratches do not stand out.
  • Large slab sizes are available (up to 2.4m x 1.35m), making it versatile for various hearth sizes.

However, there have been some challenges with Italian slate over the years:

  • Inconsistent thickness: At times, we have received slabs as thin as 15mm instead of the expected 20mm.
  • Warped slabs: Surprisingly, slate can sometimes develop a slight bend due to geological factors.

To address these issues, Manthorpe Slate conducted an on-site review at Italian slate mines around six years ago. As a result, we now confidently supply top-tier Italian riven slate, which is riven on the top but machine-gauged underneath for flatness.

Downsides of Italian Riven Slate

  1. Acid Sensitivity: Strong acids, such as brick acid, can etch the surface of Italian slate.
  2. Higher Cost: As a premium product sourced from Italy, it is more expensive than alternatives like Brazilian slate. However, the superior quality and aesthetics make it worth the investment.

Conclusion: Which Hearth Slate is Best for You?

When choosing a hearth slate, the decision depends on your priorities:

  • If budget is a primary concern, Brazilian slate is an economical option but comes with durability trade-offs.
  • If longevity, durability, and aesthetics are your main criteria, Italian riven slate is the best choice.
  • If you can source it, Welsh slate remains the most prestigious option but is increasingly rare in riven form.

At Manthorpe Slate, we remain committed to providing high-quality, reliable hearth slates to suit a variety of needs. With our carefully selected Italian riven slate, you can enjoy both beauty and durability in your hearth for years to come. Visit our bespoke hearth slate page to find out more.

Hearth slate closeup
close up of Italian riven slate showing the grain